Many of us look forward to the Holiday season. It’s a time to reconnect with old friends, spend time with family, and enjoy over-the-top, gut-busting meals and rich, indulgent desserts. It’s also a great time of year to crack open that bottle of single malt Scotch whisky you’ve been holding onto all year. Few things go better with holiday revelry than a well-made whisky.
Sure, a case can be made for a nice single malt aged in sherry-seasoned barrels or even a unique rum cask-aged whisky, but I believe the best choice for holiday sipping is a complex, smoky single malt. And if we’re talking about peat-smoked whiskies, we’re talking about the Inner Hebrides island of Islay.
Off the coast of Scotland sits an island that’s home to around 3,000 people and more than 65,000 sheep. It’s also home to some of the country’s most well-known single malt whisky distilleries, including Lagavulin, Ardbeg, Bruichladdich, and Laphroaig. Most of the distilleries craft whiskies made with peat-smoked barley.
What is peated whisky?

While not all smoky whisky is peated, most of it is. And that’s what we’re going to talk about today. Peated whisky is made from malted barley dried over a fire made from peat. For those who aren’t familiar, peat is a dark brown, soil-like material made from partially decomposed plants like grass, moss, and more. Super concentrated, it’s been used as a fuel to heat homes in Scotland, Ireland, and other places for centuries (although its popularity is waning as more modern fuel sources become available). It’s also used to flavor peated whisky.
Why is smoky whisky a great choice for the holidays?

There are myriad reasons why smoky whisky is a great choice for the holiday season. It’s rich, robust, smoky, and effortlessly warming during the colder months. It’s the type of whisky you’ll want to savor while you sit beside a warm fire on a frigid winter night. It also works well when paired with savory, heavy winter meals and desserts.
How I pick my smoky single malts

When I pick my smoky single malt whiskies, I’m looking for both balance and pleasant smoke. There are smoke bombs aplenty if that’s your thing. But. I’m looking for a mix of peat smoke, vanilla, salted caramel, oak, and dried fruits. All in all, I’m looking for a smoky whisky that tastes like Christmas in a dram. I’m also not looking for whiskies that are over-the-top expensive. Luckily, there are plenty of options perfect for sharing with friends and family during the upcoming holiday season.
The best smoky single malts for the holidays

Now that you’ve learned a little about what a smoky whisky is, what peat is (and how it’s used in homes and in the whisky-making process), and why this is the perfect single malt whisky for the holiday season, it’s time to find some to add to your holiday bar cart. Below, you’ll find some of the absolute best smoky single malt Scotch whiskies to drink this holiday season and well into winter. Keep scrolling to see which whiskies to pour at your holiday soirees.
Ardbeg An Oa

First released in 2017, this non-age-statement peated single malt whisky is not only a great gateway into the style, but also the type of whisky you’ll want on hand at all times. Bottled at 46.6% ABV, this non-chill filtered expression is a blend of whiskies aged in Pedro Ximénez sherry casks, ex-bourbon barrels, and charred virgin oak. The whiskies were married together in a French oak vat, giving it a nuanced, balanced, highly memorable flavor profile. It all begins with a nose of sticky toffee pudding, dried fruits, candied orange peels, ocean brine, and rich peat smoke. The palate is centered on hints of fruitcake, cinnamon candy, toasted vanilla beans, orange peels, caramel, and campfire smoke. The finish is lingering and warm, ending with a mix of caramelized sugar, vanilla, dried cherries, and gentle peat smoke.
Caol Ila 12

If you’ve never tried any whiskies from Caol Ila, the holidays are the perfect time to change that. Start with Caol Ila 12 Year Old, a 43% ABV smoky, memorable expression you’ll always want on hand. This gateway peated whisky was matured for at least 12 years, mostly in ex-bourbon barrels. It’s lighter and more approachable than many of the other Islay single malts. It all starts with aromas of salted caramel, orange zest, caramel apples, clover honey, and light campfire smoke. Sipping it reveals hints of cracked black pepper, toasted vanilla beans, honey, dried fruits, candied orange peels, and peaty smoke. The finish is long and warm, ending with a mix of citrus, baking spices, and robust smoke.
Talisker 10 Year Old

If you’re looking to stray slightly away from Islay, head to the Isle of Skye to try Talisker 10 Year Old. This 45.8% well-balanced single malt whisky was matured for a minimum of 10 years in ex-bourbon American oak barrels. The result is a smoky, sweet, spicy whisky worth savoring all winter long. It all begins with a nose of ocean brine, toasted vanilla beans, candy apples, and rich peaty smoke. The palate is centered on notes of candied orange peels, sea salt, honey, caramelized sugar, vanilla beans, and ever-present peat smoke. The finish is medium in length, warm, and ends with a mix of caramel sweetness, cracked black pepper, and campfire smoke.
Lagavulin 16

If you only purchase one smoky whisky on this list, make it Lagavulin 16. There’s a reason this whisky constantly makes “best of” lists. This 43% ABV peat-smoked whisky was matured for at least 16 years in a combination of barrels, including American oak and sherry casks. This results in a smoky, balanced, sippable whisky perfect for the holiday season and beyond. It opens with notes of salted caramel, iodine, toasted vanilla beans, pipe tobacco, cocoa, dried fruits, and swirling peat smoke. Sipping it brings flavors like maple candy, caramelized sugar, ocean brine, honey, raisins, iodine, baking spices, and rich campfire smoke. The finish is medium in length, warm, and ends with a balance of caramel candy, cracked black pepper, dry oak, and peaty smoke.