Skip to main content

Why Simple Carbon Dioxide Is the Hottest New Ingredient in Modern Winemaking

Carbonic maceration is without a doubt one of the cooler phrases in winemaking. It sounds like the name of an epic electronic band or the title of a great sci-fi sequel.

In reality, the term refers to a particular style of fermentation at the winery. Grapes ferment while fully intact and still in their skins, creating an unctuous wine with a low tannin count. These wines are juicy and ready to drink pretty much right when they’re bottled, unlike more conventionally produced wines which require more time to even out.

carbonic maceration
Siegfried Layda/Shutterstock

Carbon dioxide persuades the grapes to ferment and is introduced to tanks and bins to create an anaerobic climate. Whereas more traditional winemaking fermentation banks on yeast and its impact on pressed juice, this approach is full of countless mini-fermentations. Inside every grape, a tiny fermentation is sparked by CO2. Meanwhile, the weight of the fruit naturally presses some of the lower layers of clusters, creating some free run juice (part of the saignée approach).

The rise in bright, immediately approachable wines like Gamay Noir in the last decade has popularized the style. But it goes back to Beaujolais in France, where the style was perfected and first noted by scientists in the 19th century. Because it’s a mostly natural approach, carbonic maceration in some form of another goes back much farther, before the days of yeast strains, climate control, and more became the norm.

Carbonic maceration almost always involves red grapes, as the phenolic transformation tends to backfire with whites, creating off-flavors or unwanted aromatics. It has a long history in France but is being utilized by other European countries, too. In the states, intrepid producers are using carbonic maceration to make their own nouveau-style wines, packed with freshness. Even the coffee realm is showing interest in the style.

At Corollary Wines in the Willamette Valley, the focus is on bubbles. Husband-and-wife team Jeanne Feldkamp and Dan Diephouse planned to celebrate their first vintage at a wine bar in Portland earlier this year. But the pandemic and resulting lockdown had other ideas.

The couple believes that Oregon’s most famous appellation is the best place on planet Earth for making sparkling wine. They gained an angle after tasting some memorable wines abroad, lifted by the distinctive fermentation style. “We’re big fans of carbonic in general,” Feldkamp says. “Whether it’s Lapierre in Morgon or Hervé Souhaut in the Rhone, these wines and their hedonistic aromatics are just so delicious we have a hard time keeping any in our cellar.”

She says carbonic maceration was a big part of the duo’s winemaking journey and a cellar decision that could the character of Oregon Pinot Noir in sparkling wine. “Carbonic creates aromatics that really jump out at you,” she continues. “Raspberry, cherry, tangerine, and cranberry all make appearances in our Momtazi Vineyard cuvée.”

There are challenges, of course. Feldkamp says the fruit must be handled with care so that no berries get crushed. “This is why we pick directly into fermentation bins and only fill them part way,” she says. Then there’s the issue of balance. “We want it to add another dimension, but not overwhelm.”

That means gently stomping of the grapes for careful extraction, managing temperature, and trying to hold on to the uniqueness of the site (something Momtazi has a lot of). Too much extraction, and bitterness can take over. Not enough, and you lack the color and structure necessary for a good wine. Meanwhile, you’re making sure the fermentation is still moving along and, if you’re like most winemakers, you’re dealing with a handful of other fermentations, rackings, pressings, and more at the same time.

“The final challenge is acid retention,” she says. “Because the carbonic maceration process eats up all the malic acid in the juice, you end up with a softer wine compared to traditional fermentation. This can be part of the appeal if you do it right, though. For us, a softer wine that also offers great texture and savory aspects from the saignée process can be incredibly food-friendly — even for foods you wouldn’t traditionally associate with sparkling wine, like pork chops!”

Carbonic maceration has the ability to make lighter, fresher wines with some less expected flavors. For the impatient wine drinker who lusts for instant gratification, the cellar method is a godsend. It’s also a great way to enjoy wines with plenty of structure and, generally, lower ABV levels. Drop the term the next time you’re at the bottle shop or looking for something new and different to buy online.

Editors' Recommendations

Mark Stock
Mark Stock is a writer from Portland, Oregon. He fell into wine during the Recession and has been fixated on the stuff since…
Why Some Wineries Are Aging Their Wines Underwater
edivo vino bottles on beach

Ever since some Champagne was recovered from a sunken ship in the Baltic Sea in 2010, there’s been a renewed interest in underwater wines. The bubbly was reported to be in great condition, despite being 170 years old. The ocean’s combination of darkness, cool temperature, and pressure created idyllic aging conditions for the 168 bottles on board.

Wineries have considered the approach for ages. For sparkling wine, especially, the ocean offers a cool and pressurized environment that invited longevity. But still wines appreciate the habitat as well. Like a musty old underground cellar, the ocean is without a lot of the things that can potentially harm wine, like light and heat (the impact of thirsty sharks has yet to be explored fully).
Today, there are a handful of labels taking advantage of what they claim is a special oceanic touch. In Chile, Cavas Submarinas ages some of its work in an under-the-sea cave. The label touts the many benefits of the Chilean sea and noticeable influence of the Humboldt Current (aka “Peru Current”), a cold and low-salinity South American ocean flow.
The cave’s location is a secret but the winery does extend occasional tours to the undisclosed spot. Ashore, the fruit is grown in the Itata Valley. Cavas Submarinas focuses on a handful of white and reds, including blends and a Pinot Noir. They’re assembled on land and then a select few, like the Reserva Marina, are aged underwater for three months.

Read more
Why You Need to Care About Wine Tariffs (and What People Are Doing About It)
wine tariff glass money

It’s been a particularly jittery couple of months for the American wine realm. Anxious remarks have been made by all, through social media avenues, on podcasts, and among themselves, all in the still-looming shadow of significant tariffs.

To be clear, this isn’t the healthy kind of anxiety that envelopes producers before, say, their wines are scored by a big publication. This is the kind of unfair and unjust treatment that’s put an entire industry in jeopardy. As countless voices within wine (and this very much extends into the larger galaxy of food and drinks) arena have already suggested, so much is on the potential chopping block. As in tens of thousands of American jobs and ocean-spanning relationships between wineries and distributors — relationships that can take years to forge.

Read more
After the Grapes Are Picked: Winter Winemaking Roles
winter winemaking roles 3

You can hold the title of winemaker, but the role is going to ask much more of you than just making wine. The winter months technically make up the offseason, falling after the hectic harvest stretch. Yet, there’s plenty to do, in vineyard rows, quiet cellars, or on the road with business cards at the ready.
Brad Ford makes wine for Illahe Vineyards in Dallas, Oregon. The Willamette Valley label has become admired for its expressive wines, which range from Pinot Noir and Pinot Gris to Grüner Veltliner and a Rosé of Tempranillo. Ford’s known during crush to man a custom bike pump, which can maneuver wine around without the aid of the electrical grid. He’s also becoming an off-season enthusiast.

“Winter is rapidly becoming my favorite season out here,” he says, acknowledging that it’s not always easy given the dark and chilly days. “It’s exciting to have a new year with all of its potential to think about.”
One of his favorite tasks is pruning in the vineyard, which Ford equates to bonsai. “We’re shaping the plant both for production and shape,” he says. “Cane pruning is more difficult than other types and still isn’t automated. It requires years of experience to make the correct cuts. After twenty years, we’re beginning to see beautiful, gnarly heads forming on our Pinot plants.”
At the winery, it’s a quiet time for simpler tasks, reflection, and dreams about the future. Many of the wines are finishing malolactic fermentation and those in the barrel need to be topped routinely to prevent oxidation. “Aside from that, we’ll be spending some time bottling the 2018 wine and racking,” Ford adds.

Read more