Skip to main content
  1. Home
  2. Food & Drink
  3. Features

How to make a grown-up Jell-O shot like a NYT best American restaurant does

An elevated twist on the gelatinous drink

Pascual Jell-O shots.
Pascual

Remember Jell-O shots? Well, like cargo pants, middle parts, and Cosmopolitan cocktail recipes, they’re back. But this time, they’re going next level.

Pascual is a modern Mexican restaurant in Washington, D.C. The spot has received extensive press, including being named on the NYT’s esteemed best American restaurants list. But don’t worry—the eatery is not above a good old-fashioned Jell-O shot.

Pascual Jell-O shots.
Pascual

As the restaurant says, this ain’t your college weekend party drink. This is an elegant take, one that actually borrows from some tradition. With mezcal service, it’s common to enjoy fruit alongside the beverage. That fruit is usually citrus, hit with some chili salt.

Recommended Videos

Pascual recently served these Jell-O shots as part of its first course. The idea is a lower-ABV shot, so you don’t have to feel guilty about having a few. And, being Jello-O shots, they’re just plain fun.

The restaurant opened early last year in the nation’s capital. The name refers to the saint of cooks and the cuisine is centered around a wood-fired hearth. In the kitchen, you’ll find James Beard semifinalists for the Mid-Atlantic region in chefs Matt Conroy and Isabel Coss.

Like most people, we’re suckers for nostalgia and this drink has that theme covered. Best, it won’t leave you with a headache. And it comes at an ideal time, as we look for refreshing beverages for dinner parties and outdoor gatherings.

When we heard they were concocting such a thing at the restaurant, we had to get our hands on a recipe. Fortunately, the restaurant obliged.

Mandarin and Mezcal Jell-O Shots

Pascual Jell-O shots.
Pascual

What’s not to like? From the bright color to the playful presentation, this is a grown-up version of the party-started we know so well. As always, seek out fresh citrus and play around with the mezcals you choose to zero in on your favorite. We like how it all comes together here, a mix of savory, sweet, spicy, and tart. If you’re more of a tequila person, or even dabble in Sotol, feel free to go those routes and see what sticks. Perhaps it will inspire a new recipe that further reimagines the Jell-O shot. This recipe comes via Suzy Critchlow, the beverage director with The Popal Group.

Ingredients:

  • 250 grams mandarin juice
  • 50 grams mezcal
  • 10 grams wildflower honey vinegar
  • 50 grams lime
  • 100 grams 1:1 simple syrup (white sugar)
  • 8 sheets of gelatin

Method:

  1. Combine liquid ingredients.
  2. Bloom gelatin in ice water for 5-10 minutes (until floppy).
  3. Gently heat a half portion of the combined liquid ingredients in sauce pan. Wring excess water from gelatin sheet and stir to dissolve in sauce pan. Remove from heat and combine with other portion of juice. Pour into desired vessels and leave to firm in fridge overnight. (At Pascual, we save the husks of the citrus as the vessel.) Sprinkle with chili salt to serve.

If you need some inspiration for your bottle choice, check out our guide to mezcal as well as our feature on the most exciting mezcals on the market. Agave spirits continue to be all the rage, so read up so you know what’s in your cup. Here’s to elevated sipping.

Mark Stock
Mark Stock is a writer from Portland, Oregon. He fell into wine during the Recession and has been fixated on the stuff since…
Yellowstone Bourbon is releasing a limited edition whiskey finished in port wine casks
If you enjoy port-finished whiskeys, you'll love this new release
Yellowstone Limited Edition 2026

Yellowstone National Park is one of America’s most popular parks. At more than 2 million acres, it’s home to Old Faithful, Mammoth Hot Springs, and countless elk, bears, and massive bison. Recently, Yellowstone Bourbon announced the release of a unique new expression: Yellowstone Limited Edition 2026.

Yellowstone Limited Edition 2026

Read more
Heaven Hill is launching a new, unique bottled-in-bond bourbon
Bottled-in-bond fans will love this new release from Heaven Hill
Heaven Hill Bottled-in-Bond Double Mash

Heaven Hill is known for its award-winning portfolio of whiskeys. One of the most popular is its Bottled-in-Bond Bourbon. Fans of this expression will be excited to learn about the release of an innovative new product: Heaven Hill Bottled-in-Bond Double Mash.

Heaven Hill Bottled-in-Bond Double Mash

Read more
Glenglassaugh adds a 15-year-old to its permanent coastal single malt range
The Highland distillery's new core expression spends 15 years in Pedro Ximénez sherry and Spanish wine casks.
Alcohol, Beverage, Liquor

When a Scotch company adds a new permanent bottling, that's news. When that same distillery is Glenglassaugh, which has some of the most interesting history in all of Scotch whisky, that's something to really pay attention to.

Their latest is a 15-year-old single malt, joining the flagship 12 Year Old as the second age-statement bottle in the coastal Highland distillery's core range.

Read more