Skip to main content

Are you overtraining?The fitness trap that anyone can fall into

Doing too much is a common workout problem

young man doing cardio workout at the gym
Samuel Borges Photography / Canva Pro

If you’re athletically-oriented, your approach to fitness and workouts is structured. You have goals. Plans. A solid routine. You make room for changes and unexpected bad days, but what happens when you hit your goals and it doesn’t feel fulfilling?

This happened to me recently. I’m a lifelong runner, and my latest goal was to go from five miles a day to six, then duplicate that distance six days a week. It took weeks of hard work, but I when I finally got over the hump, I felt nothing, just a strange, unfamiliar combination of flatness and fatigue. It was a vexing problem, and it took me a while to understand that I’d succumbed to one of the most common problems in fitness — overtraining.

Recommended Videos

A common story

Man getting ready to run on running track
Olly / Pexels

Having overtrained before, I had a history to tap into, which gave me a solid starting point. But getting good advice to deal with overtraining is much harder than it looks, and Kristina Centenari, a trainer for Tonal, usually starts with a basic approach to the problem.

“I look at patterns,” she says. “[What’s] the training load? The volume? How about frequency?”

But those basic patterns often aren’t enough. Sometimes Centenari has to go deeper into the problem and ask questions she hopes will be more revealing.

“What role is lifestyle stress playing?” Centenari adds. “Are there holes in [your] nutrition?”

The sum total of these questions is often psychological. Taken together, they can expose a mindset that sets up a situation where overtraining is all but inevitable.

“You won’t feel motivated every day, but when you feel sluggish, really lacking enthusiasm, or even heightened stress or anxiety, that’s when we should take a look at the bigger picture,” she explains. “You need to track your recovery like you track your training, and don’t wait until your performance drops to do it.”

Overtraining adjustments you can make

Man doing plank with pre-workout supplement
Andrea Piacquadio / Pexels

This kind of analysis and thought process can lead to a viable plan. Centenari has a laundry list of steps that can help with overtraining, and there’s no room for a “one size fits all” approach in her process.

  • More “deload” weeks
  • Reduce overall volume
  • Implement lighter intensity days where you incorporate walking, working on mobility, etc.
  • Set protein goals
  • Set sleep goals
  • Encourage some form of breath work or meditation

How I solved my overtraining problem

Man running on the beach at sunset
Samsilitongajr / Pexels

So how did I solve my own overtraining problem? The solution definitely incorporated analyzing my own patterns, but beyond that my solution was very individual.

In making the jump from five miles to six, I’d been focusing on long, slow distance. It took me a while to figure it out, but finally I realized that my pace was a real problem.

Simply put, I was running too slowly. This produced a lot of flat, uninspiring runs where I was simply going through the motions in any ways.

As a result, I began increasing my pace — slowly, a little bit at a time. When this proved easier than I thought I would be, I realized I was on to something. My runs became more lively and enjoyable, and I also made some minor nutritional adjustments while adding extra naps to my routine.

Given my tendency to set goals, I know I’ll probably overtrain again at some point in the future. But having a list of possible adjustments is comforting, and anyone can incorporate them into their routine. Overtraining doesn’t have to be a debilitating problem, especially if you recognize the signs early on and take steps to alter your routine.

Bob McCullough
Bob McCullough is a freelance author and journalist who has published dozens of novellas and novels, and his journalism has…
Topics
I wore the Oura Ring for three months and it changed the way I look at fitness
My experience with the Oura Ring
Oura Ring

I’m a huge fan of fitness gadgets. If there’s a new wearable making waves, chances are I’ve already tried it or at least added it to my wishlist. Over the years, I’ve been wowed by a few and let down by many. From tracking every step with an Apple Watch to analyzing my workouts with a Garmin, I’ve tested just about every fitness tracker on the market. So when I started noticing the Oura Ring showing up on the fingers of wellness influencers, elite athletes, and even friends who don’t usually care about this stuff, my curiosity kicked in.

The Oura Ring promised something different: a sleek, screenless wearable that focused less on how many workouts you crushed and more on how well you recover, sleep, and handle stress. I ordered the sizing kit, picked out the Rose Gold color, and committed to wearing it every day. And while I wouldn’t use it as my sole fitness tracker, especially for in-depth workout stats, after three months, I can confidently say the Oura Ring changed the way I think about fitness. It helped me shift from obsessing over numbers and calorie burn to understanding my body’s rhythms and prioritizing recovery.

Read more
Can this simple activity lower the risk of 13 cancers? Interesting new study
Research shows walking can lower blood pressure and the symptoms of depression, but what about the risk of cancer?
man walking outside wearing glasses

When I’m not sitting at my computer, I’m trying to stretch my legs and get my muscles moving and my blood circulating. Researchers associated a sedentary lifestyle with a higher risk of cancer, cardiovascular disease, and metabolic diseases. Recently, I’ve covered the growing research on the benefits of exercise and on walking, which is natural, simple, accessible, and good for your body. 

For example, one study revealed that maintaining a brisk walking pace lowers your risk of developing dementia later in life. Walking can also improve your blood sugar, and just a 10-minute walk around the block can lower blood pressure and perk up your mood. Previous research has shown that physical activity can lower the risk of cancer, and a new study from the University of Oxford further explored this association. Does walking really lower your risk of cancer? Does more steps mean an even lower risk? Let’s look at the study.

Read more
Should you lift weights before or after cardio to maximize gains? New study
Should you run first or pick up those dumbbells? What does the latest research show?
man lifting weights dumbbells woman training

We all have our preferences, but many fitness enthusiasts prefer to do cardio before strength training. While lots of people like to get their blood circulating with cardio first, others prefer to get started on the weights or machines. Does it matter? Which is best when it comes to losing fat while gaining strength? While many are still recommending that you do what feels best for you, others are touting the research on the benefits of doing weight training first. Recently, researchers explored whether weight training before hitting the treadmill is more efficient for fat reduction and improving strength. 

The research

Read more