Skip to main content

Yesterday’s: A New Bar With Old New York Soul

The new neighborhood bar pairs classic cocktails, comfort food, and Knicks fever with the feel of a decades-old public house.

By Johnny Motley Published June 13, 2026

Architecture, Building, Person — Yesterday's / Jess Bozzello

Sports mania is tearing through New York City like norovirus on a cruise ship. As the Knickerbockers stage their heroic run toward an NBA championship, skyscrapers glow in blue and orange each night. In Central Park, strangers congregate around wheeled-in televisions, sharing beer and fellowship like friars in a Trappist monastery. My girlfriend, a Midwestern transplant in Bushwick, has become so Knicks-crazed that I’m afraid she may tattoo Jalen Brunson’s likeness on her torso. And as if basketball fever weren’t enough, the World Cup has begun.

Bandwagoning With the Knicks at an Old-School New York Tavern

My own attitude toward professional athletics mirrors that of the great satirist H.L. Mencken: “I hate all sports as rabidly as a person who likes sports hates common sense.” But I’m no curmudgeon, at least not completely. Though indifferent to the games themselves, I’m enjoying the pageantry, collective euphoria, and festive spirit in my adopted hometown. If nothing else, it’s been a wonderful excuse to drink with my friends.

Recommended Videos

Which brings me to Yesterday’s, the bar I patronized to watch Game 4 of the NBA Finals. It only opened last April, but it deliberately feels like an old-school New York public house. The banquette seating, penny tile floors, and wood wainscoting make you think the place has been pouring pints since the Knicks last won a title in 1973.

Keeping with the nostalgic theme, the cocktails are firmly rooted in the classics. No esoteric amari, fat washes, or smoke-filled glass contraptions—just rock-solid martinis, Manhattans, and Negronis, alongside a small but thoughtful wine list.

Executive Chef Robert Sieber, whose résumé includes Daniel Boulud’s DB Bistro Moderne and the Michelin-starred Jungsik, cooks luxurious and comforting bar food. Once the game started, we ordered a mess of shareable snacks—fried olives, mozzarella sticks, and chicken wings. The wagyu cheeseburger I wolfed down after my third martini was sheer delight.

A bar that intentionally evokes a bygone New York was a fitting venue to watch the Knicks make history. I still won’t learn the names of the players—except for that Brunson fellow my girlfriend keeps going on about—but I’m tickled to see New York City in such a joyful mood. And thanks to the Knicks, I discovered a terrific new bar in the West Village. Just don’t invite me out for the World Cup. Fútbol remains a bridge too far.

Author

Johnny covers travel, men's fashion and whiskey.

Food & Drink

These are my favorite beers from Vermont that you should give a try

Vermont is home to more than Ben & Jerry

Lawson's Finest

There are about 9,000 breweries in the US. While places like California, Maine, Colorado, and Oregon are famous for beer, no state is more saturated with IPAs, lagers, and stouts than Vermont.

If you didn’t know it, Vermont is much more than the state that brought us Ben & Jerry. The New England state is arguably America’s beer capital. While it doesn’t have the population of some of the other beer centers, it’s number one per capita, with more than 74 breweries. That’s between 14.5 and 15 breweries per 100,000 people. This includes iconic breweries like The Alchemist, Foam, Lawson’s Finest Liquids, Zero Gravity, and the renowned Hill Farmstead Brewery.

Food & Drink

The Best Restaurant in New York for Catching Up with an Old Friend

Date restaurants have one set of criteria; restaurants for catching up with your buddies have another.

Food, Food Presentation, Plate

Finding a restaurant in New York City for a proper catch-up with a buddy is deceptively tricky. When I was single, I kept a tried-and-true roster of date restaurants. The criteria were straightforward enough: soft lighting, ideally the glow of candlelight; a serene ambience, perhaps with a little jazz; and plush, private seating for lingering conversation—or a smooch after dessert.

But what about dinner with my cousin Billy? I was less than eager to spend the evening feeling like I was on a Hinge date with him—a sentiment I suspect was mutual. Sure, I could have picked a dive bar, but we're both in our mid-thirties now and striving to feign respectability. Besides, Bill draws a fat salary at Amazon, and I knew he'd feel obliged to pick up the tab for his freelance writer cousin. Why squander such generosity on chicken wings and Guinness?

Food & Drink

The bottles of bourbon you should always have on your bar cart

Stock your home bar with these balanced bourbons

Bourbon bottle

Other than the designated hitter, apple pie, and ranch dressing, there are few things more uniquely American than bourbon whiskey. While there are a variety of rules, to be considered bourbon whiskey, it must be made from at least 51% corn (with many having a much higher percentage) and be made in the US (including Puerto Rico and DC). Regardless of what a whiskey purist might tell you, it doesn’t need to be produced in Kentucky (although more than 90% of it still is made in the Bluegrass State). That said, if you’re new to this type of whiskey, you need to start somewhere. Lucky for you, I’m here to help.

If you were to magically rewind my life about two decades, I would easily have been able to refer to myself as a bourbon beginner. Back then, I had only sampled a few whiskeys (mostly in cocktails) and couldn’t tell the difference between Johnnie Walker and Jim Beam. Over the years (and with a ton of writing, researching, and sampling), I’ve learned that not only are there major differences between Scotch, bourbon, and other whisk(e)ys, but also that there are a handful of bourbon whiskeys that everyone should stock on their home bar at all times.