Skip to main content
  1. Home
  2. Food & Drink
  3. Reviews

Peter Luger and the Great New York Steak Dinner

A tale of steak, shenanigans, and excess at New York’s archetypal steakhouse.

Brunch, Food, Cup
Mark McKee / Peter Luger

On the walk from Marcy Avenue station to Peter Luger, my phone buzzed with a string of text messages from Bill, another writer for The Manual.

Recommended Videos

“Dude! Mark said he’s having dinner with you at Luger,” he wrote, referring to our boss and editor-in-chief.

“Def have a pre-dinner whisky at the bar and order the famous bacon. It’s probably my favorite steakhouse in America, but that’s great you invited Mark!”

“Btw, I’m actually in the neighborhood. I was going to meet a date at Maison Premiere, but she forgot she had dinner plans with her parents.”

I left him on read.

Mark and I arrived for our seven o’clock reservation, and the maître d’ curtly informed us that a member of our party was already seated.

“Your colleague Bill explained the misunderstanding. Next time, make sure the reservation matches the number of guests.”

Beefsteak when I’m hungry, rye whiskey when I’m dry/
Greenbacks when I’m hard up,
And heaven when I die. – Jack O’ Diamonds

Peter Luger is often hailed as the archetypal New York steakhouse. In The Sopranos, Tony has an indelible line about dining at Luger so regularly that he practically paid for its new wing. Opened in 1887, when Williamsburg was a German enclave, it still bears a faint whiff of the old Teutonic beer hall—German fried potatoes, apple strudel with schlag, ceramic steins lining the bar. At some point, the place became as fanatical about steak as Luther was about ecclesiastical purity. It’s the Cologne Cathedral of marbled beef.

We sat at a table in the original dining room next to a large window overlooking Driggs Avenue—right and proper for Mark’s first spin. Bill and I, both Luger veterans, took the lead in ordering. As we drained pints of Luger Lager, a sizzling plate of thick-as-your-thumb bacon hit the table alongside a bowl of Luger’s steak sauce. Next, shrimp cocktail with fresh horseradish. I called for neat pours of Michter’s to settle our nerves before what was coming next. The hero course was a porterhouse for three, lobster tail, creamed spinach, German fried potatoes, and a ’21 Far Niente Cabernet Sauvignon.

Buzzed and as sated as wolves after a kill, we polished off a slice of cheesecake and apple strudel with schlag, a Bavarian-style whipped cream that Luger serves by the bowlful. The waiter approached with the check, and Bill excused himself from the table. Mark and I lingered over the bill until the waiter made his third attempt to collect.

Bill reappeared just as we were signing our receipts.

“Gentlemen, a dinner for the ages. The food was surpassed only by the company. What was the damage, by the way?”

I showed him the copy of the receipt. A long pause.

“So I actually can’t use Venmo or Zelle anymore. I’d rather not get into the details. But just give me your mailing addresses. I’d be delighted to send you a check.”

Johnny covers travel, men’s fashion and whiskey. Read Full Bio
Planteray’s new Extreme Series is made from six “unicorn barrels” around the world of rum
Rum, Bottles, Liquor

Every booze release can tell you a story about the liquid, but Planteray’s new drop tells the tales of six barrels, six countries, and the people behind them.

The rum brand, owned by French company Maison Ferrand and produced at Stade’s West Indies Rum Distillery in Barbados, just released Extreme Series VI: Legends of Rum, a six-bottle collection of single-cask rums from around the Caribbean and the Pacific.

Read more
Blue Run Spirits is launching a limited-edition bourbon to celebrate Texas
Blue Run

They say the “stars at night are big and bright” deep in the heart of Texas. Whether you’re sitting somewhere now where you can see those stars or not, as long as you have love for the Lone Star State, you’ll be glad to hear about the newest release from Blue Run Spirits. That’s because the award-winning spirits brand announced the launch of a Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey paying tribute to Matthew McConaughey’s home state.

Blue Run Blueprint Series Texas Butterfly Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Read more
Chattanooga Whiskey is launching a liqueur perfect for Hot Toddy fans
Chattanooga Whiskey

If you enjoy creative, unique whiskeys, you’re likely already on the Chattanooga Whiskey bandwagon—specifically, the Chattanooga Whiskey Experimental Distillery. While you can’t go wrong with anything from this innovative distillery, the brand announced a truly interesting new spirit. One that is perfect for the cold months ahead.

Experimental Single Batch Series: Batch 049: Honey Hot Toddy

Read more