When we woke up this morning, one of the most prolific and sought-after actors of our time, Robert Pattinson, held the future in his hands for two of the biggest, most profitable, and beloved franchises in cinema. He was Batman; he was the billionaire, playboy orphan who transformed himself to the peak of human condition to fight crime on the streets of Gotham. And, it was rumored, that he was Amazon’s top choice to take on the role of everyone’s favorite debonair spy, James Bond. Now, it is official: he has been cast, and the role of a lifetime is now his. We have our Bond. We have our director. We have a direction, and we can start thinking about what the future of this franchise will look like.
So, what does it look like? Let’s talk about it. Here is the good, the bad, and the ugly truth about the casting of Robert Pattinson as James Bond.
James Bond is one of the most legendary characters in cinema, and to be entrusted with 007 is the honour of a lifetime. – Robert Pattinson
The good

This may be controversial. It may not be. I am getting this out there first, so maybe it will contradict the naysayers. Robert Pattinson may be the perfect choice to play 007. If you are a fan of the novels, you know that many of the James Bond actors were the perfect film version of the character. Someone like Roger Moore or Timothy Dalton was a little further removed from the look of Bond. Sean Connery was the closest to the character. Brosnan was the perfect suave and debonair side while not being as physical, and Craig was the perfect physical side without the pretty shell. I have been saying from the beginning that the next Bond should be a mix of them both. And Pattinson may be that. He is pretty enough to pull off the debonair. And he is physical enough to give us the grit. To put an even finer point on it, look at the original James Bond drawing from Fleming, and you will see Pattinson is the closest one to staring back at you from the page. It will be interesting to see if the makeup department gives him the scar on his cheek.
“I’m deeply grateful to Denis, Amy, David, Tanya, and everyone at Amazon MGM Studios for their belief in me. To say this role is a dream come true is an understatement. I couldn’t be more excited about this partnership and the work ahead with this fantastic team,” Pattinson said.
The bad

Ok, for the bad. I can already hear it. “You mean the vampire guy?” The same thing that was said when Pattinson landed the role as Batman is going to be the same thing said here. The danger of casting an actor who is a somebody (something EON Productions would never do) is that you run the risk of Bond being someone else. Will Pattinson be Bond? Or will Bond be Pattinson? This is largely an audience problem. If there is any actor in Hollywood who has worked harder to shed the typecast of a role they played two decades ago, it is Pattinson (maybe you could argue his cast mate Kristen Stewart is the other one). If you still view Pattinson as Edward, I have some homework for you.
The Odyssey, Primetime, Mickey 17, and a whole slew of movies from the last decade show he can disappear into a role. The Lighthouse is one of the more underrated movies in the last ten years, and if you ever wanted to know if Pattinson could act, this is the movie that shows you what he has. People were hesitant when they found out this guy was going to play Batman, and now those same people are upset they have had to wait for more. Finally, there is already a little bit of a soft audition out there of him as James Bond in TENET, an underseen Christopher Nolan film from 2020 that felt like a dry run for him as 007.
In any case, the bad thing that happens with any casting of a beloved character: prepare for the internet to melt down the same way they did with Daniel Craig before him, or Heath Ledger as Joker, or even Pattinson himself as Batman. I would caution you to reserve judgment until you see him.
One last piece that could be a bad thing: It is rumored Amazon offered him a short contract with fewer movies than everyone else. If that is the case, this entire process could start over in a few short years.
The ugly

Now for the element in the room. The ugly truth about this news is that it means we will likely see the end of his run as Batman. As I said at the beginning, it seemed he was holding the keys to two massive franchises. It always felt like he was going to have to choose one, as there is little chance he could hold down two of them and still have a career outside them. The truth is that the firing of James Gunn and Peter Safran signaled a likelihood that the DCU would be rebooting. There were dozens of rumors that they wanted Pattinson’s Batman to join in Corensweat’s Superman for the future of the universe. But, in the end, Warner Bros just can’t seem to get out of their own way, and the instability of the DC property with Warner Bros all but made the decision easy for Pattinson.
We are still a year or so away from getting to see him grab the Walther. With Denis Villeneuve (Dune, Blade Runner 2049, Arrival) behind the camera and Robert Pattinson in front of the camera, we are in for a Bond unlike anything we have ever seen before. And the beautiful truth is that may be exactly what we need. It worked for Craig to do something new. It will likely work for Pattinson.