Which Loafers Are the Best? And What Do You Wear with Them Anyway?

Other than pairing them for those most formal moments, what is the best way to wear them? Do they really go with everything?

Here we’ve dissected the loafer style by its various iterations and made a few suggestions for the clothes most likely to complement the shoes. Some advice: When pairing pants with loafers, don’t be afraid to go a little short on the inseam of your more formal trousers, and think about allowing a little extra length for a good cuff roll on your khakis and jeans. Get to know your tailor if buying off the peg so he can shorten pants appropriately and maybe even add a cuff for extra sartorial points. Highwaters be damned, it’s a perfect opportunity to show off a little ankle.

What to Wear with Loafers

Bass Larson Easy Weejuns
Bass Larson Easy Weejuns

The most classic loafer style is the Weejun, which is also a penny loafer. This is the one style of loafer that generations of us have had and will continue to have. It’s also considered to be a relatively casual style, so we don’t recommend wearing it with a suit. Think jeans and a blazer instead.

Mavi Marcus Slim Straight Leg Jean
Mavi Marcus Slim Straight Leg Jean

Weejuns are a perfect pairing with jeans, especially when the shoes are black, for that “cool prep” look. We like the dark wash of these Mavi’s with just a bit of stretch so they’re as comfy as your loafers. Pair these with a classic white button-down and a Shetland wool crewneck for an all-American style.

Cole Haan Bit Loafer
Cole Haan Bit Loafer

The other ultimate classic loafer style is the “bit” loafer. The equestrian-inspired style was originally made famous by the Gucci Horse Bit Loafe. But for those of us contributing to a 401-K, this Cole Haan alternative is a worthy substitute. It’s overall a “bit” dressier than the penny loafer, which means it should be paired with dress pants to look its best.

Selected Slim Fit Dress Pants
Selected Slim Fit Dress Pants

Pair bit loafers—whatever the price—with these dressier pants from Selected. They have a trim, slim fit so they hug the ankle and show off your shoes to their best advantage. Keep this look sleek with a solid dress shirt in a darker hue, and consider grabbing the matching navy blazer that complements every shoe on this page.

Magnanni Fabricio Apron Toe Slip On
Magnanni Fabricio Apron Toe Slip On

For a sleeker, dressier look that works nicely with suits, try a simple slip-on. With no ornamentation, minimal stitching and an extremely basic silhouette, the slip-on loafer borders on being a formal shoe, but it’s a great choice for days when you’re running a little behind schedule and stopping to lace or unlace might mean missing a train or being late to spin class.

Kenneth Cole New York Slim-Fit Plaid Performance Suit
Kenneth Cole New York Slim-Fit Plaid Performance Suit

This Kenneth Cole suit is a perfect pairing with a slip-on: It’s dark and somewhat proper, but the tonal plaid pattern lightens the mood to fit the ease of a loafer. Feel free to wear this with a crisp white shirt (necktie optional), solid knit polo, or a pullover sweater.

Florsheim Wingtip Loafer
Florsheim Wingtip Loafer

Starting with an elegant tassel loafer and heading right on through to the full brogue model shown here, the loafer’s simple silhouette—like any blank canvas—becomes an opportunity for the classic cobbler and contemporary fashion designer alike to express themselves. There’s a lot going on in this iconic shoe, but it has a character that is at once traditional and punk. Wear it with everything from gray flannel suits to khakis to bondage pants (if that’s your thing).

Devereux Ford 5 Pocket Pant
Devereux Ford 5 Pocket Pant

Keep it simple with an updated preppy classic. Devereux’s classic 5-pocket pant features four-way stretch in a soft Pima cotton blend. They come in a nice range of waist to length ratios, so get ‘em a little short to show off all that craftsmanship in the shoes. For an ultimate prep meets punk look, pair ‘em with Psycho Bunny’s classic polo in a bold hue, featuring the brand’s tongue-in-cheek logo. “Nightmare Before Easter,” anyone?

Timberland Wodehouse Slip-On Shoes
Timberland Wodehouse Slip-On Shoes

If you’re a guy who prefers a bit more outdoors in your style, there are plenty of rugged loafer options that are more poison ivy than Ivy League. After all, the classic boat shoe, Blucher moccs, and driving shoes are all just tough-guy versions of the loafer. We like Timberland’s Wodehouse because, although the Horween leather, contrast stitching, and rubber sole put it right at home around the campfire, the sleek silhouette makes it great for the casual office.

Ozone Loafer Socks
Ozone Loafer Socks

A word on socks worn with loafers.  Ya don’t have to, really. But for comfort’s sake…for stank’s sake…sometimes it’s a good idea. If you’re the kind of guy who needs to wear novelty socks (sigh), go for it, but try to keep them coupled with simpler styles. Otherwise—since the whole point of a loafer is that you can slip them off—we like this pair that demonstrates your wry, sophisticated sense of humor.

Richer Poorer Knox No Show 3 Pack

Alternatively, if you’re in a warm enough climate, go for a free and easy sockless look that protects your shoes and feet from smelling nasty, while still allowing for free expression.

Editors' Recommendations