Skip to main content
  1. Home
  2. Food & Drink

How to Make a Rum Old Fashioned

The Manual
By

Typically, when you think of the classic cocktail the Old Fashioned, what is the first spirit that comes to mind? Whiskey, right? Of course. More specifically, you’re probably thinking bourbon. Well, even though a bourbon Old Fashioned is what we have come to know and love, the Old Fashioned cocktail wasn’t always made with whiskey.

Let’s take a step back in time real quick. The first documentation of the word cocktail (we’ll get to the Old Fashioned part soon) happened way back in the early 1800s, when Hudson, New York’s The Balance and Columbian Repository explained (in response to a reader’s question) that a cocktail was a mix of booze, sugar, bitters, and water. Over the next couple of decades, the Old Fashioned popped up in various places, perhaps most notably in Jerry Thomas’ seminal cocktail book Jerry Thomas’ Bartender’s Guide, where he writes of an Old Fashioned Holland Gin Cocktail.

As we said, no whiskey in sight.

Related

Skip ahead another decade or so to 1881 and we get to the Old Fashioned we know and love, which was invented at the Pendennis Club in Louisville, Kentucky, in 1881 in honor of a bourbon distiller named James E. Pepper. (If you want to learn more about James E. Pepper, you can always visit the distillery that is named for him, which is now open in Lexington, Kentucky.)

Bartenders these days, it seems, are embracing the fact that Old Fashioned cocktails don’t have to be made with bourbon or whiskey. Across the country, you’ll find mezcal riffs, genever riffs, and more.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

One recipe that we came across was a rum-based Old Fashioned at Little Jack’s Tavern in Charleston, South Carolina.

Why did Little Jack’s go with rum over any other spirits? We asked general manager Marc Hudacsko to explain. “Our cocktail menu consists of all classic cocktails. Things our parents and grandparents would have enjoyed. The Old Fashioned is, of course, as old school and classic as they come. With that particular cocktail, we wanted to throw a little bit of a curveball. Rum is a huge part of the culture and history of Charleston, so we decided to pay homage to that history. Also, we love rum!”

You can’t really argue with someone who loves rum. We guess you could, but you’d just look like a jerk.

So without further ado, here is how to make a Rum Old Fashioned at home.

Rum Old Fashioned

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Method: Press one Jack Rudy cherry to the bottom of the glass. Mix all ingredients in an Old Fashioned glass. Stir about 30 revolutions with ice. Garnish with an orange peel expressed in and around the glass.

Originally published by Cator Sparks on March 29, 2017. Last updated by Sam Slaughter.

Editors' Recommendations

Topics
The Manual
The Manual
The Manual is simple — we show men how to live a life that is more engaged. Whether it be fashion, food, drink, travel…
The 10 best rosé wines that everyone should drink
It's time to finally try rosé
Rose wine glasses

Rosé rules -- no ifs, ands, or buts. You’ve most definitely seen dudes drinking rosé, with the pink wine sold in forties. Chances are, you’ve heard the term “brosé” at least once or twice in your life. Heck, people are cooking with rosé. Can you believe that? It's a sweet wine worth talking about.

All this talk about the drink prompted us to go on a quest to find the most exceptional ones this rosé season. With plenty of great options in the market, we chose to narrow down our list to these best rosé wines for your next hot date, guys' night, or solo Netflix binge. Still reluctant to try this magical wine? We listed seven reasons why you should start drinking rosé.
Best rosé wines

Read more
How to start your own home bar: the essential spirits
Home Bar

When you start getting into cocktails, drinking them is only half the fun -- making them is part of the appeal too. If you start making your own drinks at home, you'll soon find that you can often create better or more interesting drinks than what you're served in most bars. And even better, making drinks for other people is a great way to try out new combinations, learn about spirits, and make your friends and family happy too.

However, moving beyond the simple spirit plus mixer style of drinks which most people make at home and into the world of cocktails means that you'll need a wider array of spirits on hand than you might be used to. It can take some time and research to build up a well stocked bar, and choosing high quality spirits isn't a cheap endeavor. It's worth it, though, for the pleasure of being able to try out classic cocktail recipes and experiment with making up your own creations too.

Read more
You’re overlooking the most important ingredient in your cocktail
Steel Hibiscus cocktail.

When you list off the most important parts of making a good cocktail your mind likely goes immediately to good ingredients: quality spirits, freshly squeezed citrus juices, and well-matched mixers. You might also consider the importance of using the right tools, like getting a proper mixing glass so your stirred drinks can be properly incorporated, or a good strainer so that there aren't little shards of ice in your cocktails. And then there are the fun additions like elaborate garnishes, bitters, or home-made syrups which can add a personal touch to your drinks.
All of those things are important, absolutely. However I think there's one ingredient that can make or break a good cocktail, and it's something many drinkers don't ever stop to consider. It's the humble but vital ingredient of ice.

Why ice is so important
In mixed drinks like a gin and tonic or a screwdriver, ice is added to the drink primarily to chill it down to a pleasing temperature. That's a topic we'll come back to. But in cocktails which are shaken or stirred, ice is far more important than that. Cocktails are typically composed of between around 20 to 30 percent water, and this water comes from the ice used in the preparation process.
When you stir ingredients in a mixing glass or shake them in a shaker with ice, you are chipping away small pieces of the ice so that it dissolves and blends with your other ingredients. You might imagine that water doesn't make much of a difference to taste, being tasteless itself. But it's vital in opening up the flavors of other ingredients. That's why many whiskey drinkers like to add a dash of water to their whiskey when they drink it neat.
If you're ever in doubt of how important water is to cocktails, it's worth trying to make a drink with no ice. Even if you mix up the ideal ratios for a drink that you love and put it into the freezer so that it gets to the chilled temperature that you usually enjoy it at, if you sip it you'll find that your drink tastes harsh, unbalanced, and incomplete. Even for special room temperature cocktails like those designed to be drunk from a flask, you'll generally find water being added at a rate of around 30%.
When you make your cocktails you should be sure to stir for a long time – around 30 seconds is a good start – or to shake for a good while too – I typically do around 12 to 15 seconds – in order to melt enough ice to get plenty of water into your cocktail. Despite what you might imagine, this won't make the cocktail taste watery but will rather make the flavors stand out more as well as often improving the mouthfeel of the drink. A good rule of thumb is to mix or shake until the vessel is cold to the touch. That means your ingredients are sufficiently incorporated with the ice.

Read more