Skip to main content

Feasting: Pairing Cheese & Classic Cocktails with Obicà

Pairing wine and cheese together is a no brainer. But what if you’re not in the mood for wine and would prefer a classic cocktail instead? That’s the beauty of the modern food and beverage world – pretty much anything goes as long as it’s executed with care and expertise. To teach us more about how to pair the most delicious cheeses with our favorite classic cocktails, we went to Obicà, a modern restaurant imported from Italy that specializes in the freshest mozzarella di bufala Campana DOP, homemade pastas and pizzas and a killer cocktail program that’s unlike any other we’ve seen.

Related: Master Class: 5 Cocktails to Make to Impress Anyone

Recommended Videos

Founded in 2004 by Silvio Ursini, Obicà has expanded to 20 different locations, including Los Angeles and NYC, and emphasizes quality ingredients as the focus of the menu. They import their mozzarella di bufala twice a week to ensure freshness and have a two-day leavening process for their pizza dough that results in a delicate, light, crunchy crust. Flatiron Beverage Director Fabrizio Argiolas is a mixology master. All of the liquor infusions, purées and syrups are made in-house to create deliciously unexpected concoctions you can’t find anywhere else. From the Favola (carrot-infused rum, butternut squash purée, cherry peppers, citrus mix, cane syrup) to the classic Negroni, you can find a cocktail to drink with every dish on the menu. So we asked the experts at Obicà to pair cheeses with our favorite classic cocktails. But before we get your mouth watering too much, check out the signature cocktail Fabrizio made just for The Manual, and put something new in your shaker this week.

Cocktail for the Manual: by Beverage Director Fabrizio Argiolas

Nome: Smeraldo
Glass: Tumbler

3 slices of ginger
5 slices of cucumber
10 leaves of mint
1 ½ oz vodka
½ oz Dimmi Liquore di Milano
1 oz citrus mix
½ oz simple syrup

PREPARATION: Muddle the cucumber and ginger in a shaker then add the other ingredients. Fill with ice and shake for 10/15 seconds; pass through a double strainer into a tumbler glass with ice.

GARNISH: Slice of cucumber into the glass

Cheese Pairing

Smeraldo: Smoked mozzarella
Buffalo milk cheese plus the slightly smoked and juicy texture of the mozzarella is perfect with the freshness and aromatic spice of the Smeraldo and creates an amazing pairing.

cocktail-negroni-embed
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Negroni: Quadrello di bufala
Buffalo cheese with a soft texture and a perfect balance of sweetness and acidity is perfect with the characteristics of the Negroni because of its sweet and bitter tendencies

Martini: Stracciatella di burrata con Caviale
The Martini is a perfect match for the creaminess of the stracciatella di burrata and the fantastic notes of iodine from the sturgeon eggs. Excellent with the alcohol content and purity of the vodka or gin with herbal, noble notes of juniper.

Old-Fashioned: Pecorino Fiore Sardo
100% sheep’s milk aged cheese, with a powerful structure, slightly smoked with a tangy finish, matches well with the powerful alcohol and sweet-bitterness of the old-fashioned.

French 75: Mozzarella di bufala
Buffalo milk cheese is perfect with the wonderful freshness and carbonation of the French 75. The cocktail works perfectly with the freshness and juiciness of the buffalo mozzarella.

Bloody Mary: Gorgonzola
Blue cheese from cow’s milk with great complexity and a strong taste pairs well with the complex flavor and spiciness of the Blood Mary.

To learn more about Obicà, visit them at obica.com.

Amanda Gabriele
Amanda Gabriele is a food and travel writer at The Manual and the former senior editor at Supercall. She can’t live without…
7 classic tequila cocktail recipes that prove it’s more than just a party shot
Mixing a drink with tequila as the star? Here are the recipes you ought to make
Classic margarita cocktail with salty rim on wooden table with limes and drink utensils

To me, tequila always -- first and foremost -- calls to mind slammers. When I think about this spirit. I can almost taste the tequila, salt, lime, and regret. However, tequila needn't be only a party shot. In fact, it's a wonderful tool for any home bartender, as it can be mixed into a range of fruity, sour, or even savory drinks. My personal favorite is the Michelada, a savory tomato and beer-based cocktail that was a revelation the first time I tried it. It's like a funky, sharp, spicy version of a Bloody Mary, and it's an absolute pleasure to enjoy with tacos or other Mexican food.

But that's just the tip of the tequila cocktail iceberg. There are tons of beloved tequila drinks, from a classic margarita to a refreshing Paloma. Tequila goes well with sharp citrus fruits like lemon and lime and can be lengthened with fruit juices or sodas to be more sippable and less heavily boozy than in its shot form. It can also go well with more bitter flavors, if you're looking for something darker and moodier, such as a Negroni variation.

Read more
Cocktail lovers, grab this book by Death & Co while it’s 57% off
Death & Co NYC

For an easy-to-access collection of cocktail recipes, you should think about getting Death & Co: Modern Classic Cocktails -- a book that's made by the famous New York cocktail bar. Originally sold for $40, the hardcover edition is currently on sale for a very affordable $17, for huge savings of $23. The 57% discount isn't going to last forever, and since there's a possibility that it's gone as soon as tomorrow, you're going to want to proceed with your purchase of this book as soon as you can.

Why you should buy Death & Co: Modern Classic Cocktails
Whether you're an aspiring bartender or you simply love to try different cocktails, you have probably heard of Death & Co. The cocktail bar, which originated in New York, is known for all kinds of drinks, including fall cocktails, Halloween cocktails, and non-alcoholic cocktails that we've featured. Death & Co has multiple locations now, but you can try their recipes in the comfort of your own home with Death & Co: Modern Classic Cocktails, which features recipes for more than 500 cocktails that you can try to make yourself.

Read more
Make non-alcoholic versions of these classic cocktails for Dry January
Iconic cocktails, minus the alcohol
cherry-gin-cocktail

If you're doing Dry January this year then you don't just have to stick to water and sodas all month -- you might want to look into some of the options available for non-alcoholic cocktails too.

While there are plenty of great drinks options which use ingredients like fruit juices, shrubs, and sodas, one great option for the cocktail lover is to look into non-alcoholic spirits. Options like Fluère Spiced Cane, a rum alternative, or Damrak Virgin, a gin alternative, are distilled to have the flavor and drinking qualities of a spirit but without the alcohol. That makes it dead easy to swap these into classic cocktails, so you can enjoy a classic drink without the booze.
Non-Alcoholic Fluère Espresso Martini

Read more