Skip to main content
  1. Home
  2. Fashion & Style
  3. Evergreens

I traded in my puffer for a sheepskin and it was the best thing I did this winter

Sheepskin expert teaches me to wear it in the winter

Clothing, Coat, Jacket
Mark D. McKee / The Manual

I have a problem. I hate puffer coats. I know, they are warm as heck, and the function is inarguable. I wear them often when I brave the snow to shovel, scrape ice, etc. But, the inescapable truth is, they just aren’t flattering. Do you remember when you were ten years old and you had a wicked awesome Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles costume and your mom ruined it by making you put on your coat? (No? I am the only one? Well, I remember it, and it hurts) Thirty years later, the same concept holds true. The trauma of ruining my Michaelangelo costume is relived today every time I have to put a puffer coat on over one of my favorite outfits. Lucky for me, Monty Goodson exists. He has been one of the faces with Overland Sheepskin Company for decades. Nobody knows staying warm better than him. And he gave me advice that elevated my winter in amazing ways. He had me trade out my puffer for a sheepskin coat. Then, he showed me how to wear it. Since I am not a gatekeeper by nature, I will let you in on our conversation .

I think what makes sheepskin a smarter choice than a puffer is, first and foremost, its uniqueness. The styles, textures, and types of sheepskin are all so varied. Puffers generally look the same, and they’re not particularly flattering. Sheepskin contours to your own body’s shape and wraps around you in a cozy, thermal layer. – Monty Goodson, Product Development Specialist, Overland Sheepskin Company

How to wear the sheepskin

I met Monty a few years ago when I got the opportunity to tour the company’s flagship store just outside Santa Fe. While browsing, I came across this thigh-length Jackson Toscana Shearling coat. I fell in love with it immediately. Three years later, and it is my number one coat. I find myself waiting and hoping for the snow to fall simply so I can wear it. But, I had to learn how to wear it without looking like I was cosplaying Arthur Morgan in Red Dead Redemption 2. Monty had some tips for me.

Recommended Videos

“When thinking about styling a sheepskin coat versus a puffer, it all depends on the person,” Monty says. “A puffer basically looks the same; it’s a utilitarian piece that is a weather-ready cover, often made of synthetic materials.  A sheepskin reflects the wearer’s unique personality and style. Each sheepskin coat is unique and becomes even more personal as it molds to your form. You can dress a sheepskin coat up or down, all the while, draped in natural beauty and comfort.”

After giving me some pointers on how to make my sheepskin coat look either western, rock & roll, or luxurious with a rebel wink, he hits me with a bit of sheepskin wisdom. “With a sheepskin coat, it’s always as original as its owner.”

Does it hold up

Yeah, I couldn’t help it while wearing this coat. I had to throw on my Arthur Morgan hat and pretend, at least for a second, that I was in the Old West. And, the moment I put it on, I thought about the moments in the game where he was in rain, snow, and the harsh elements of the West. It made me think; this is an expensive coat, is it going to hold up in that environment? The puffer may not be flattering, but the rain, sleet, snow, ice, and seemingly even tornados can’t hurt those things. Does the sheepskin coat keep up with it?

“Sheepskin coats are made to be worn in inclement weather,” Goodson points out. “Personally, I have been snowed on, rained on, and hailed on while wearing a sheepskin coat. I just shake the excess off, lightly wipe or brush. And then let it dry naturally, with no heat. Then I’ll follow up with another light brushing or wipe down. There are a few professional dry cleaners that will clean sheepskin coats; however, as with leathers, many use solvents or chemicals that can impact the texture and color.” 

But how do you care for it

Look, I don’t mind admitting this, I am as lazy as the next guy. So I always think of how much care is going to go into something I buy. Whether or not I take on the care of a garment directly corresponds to how much I love it. Now, I love this coat, so I was ready for the hours of care a coat like this would take to keep looking as good as it does.

“Sheepskin is much easier to care for than people assume,” Monty assures me. “Depending on the surface finish and color, one can generally wipe things off with a damp, soft cloth, or if the finish is sueded, lightly brush to remove any debris. As with any natural product, shearling and leather will develop a unique character and patina over time.”

Switching to sheepskin completely revitalized my coat wardrobe. And I am never looking back to my puffer. Unless, of course, there is a ten-year-old on the street wearing a Michaelangelo costume, then I may get some use out of it yet by passing on my trauma. But, on the day to day in the winter, I know which coat I am going for. My new favorite from Overland Sheepskin Company.

Mark D McKee
Mark cut his teeth in the men's style world when he sold suits first at box stores such as Men's Wearhouse and Jos. A. Bank…
Weiss Teamed Up With a Nashville Denim Brand on a New Watch
imogene + willie tapped fellow Nashville maker Weiss Watch Co. for a hand-built, made-in-USA automatic.
Wristwatch, Watch, Strap

Nashville watchmaker Weiss Watch Company has teamed up with fellow Music City residents imogene + willie on a limited-edition release. It's snazzy, it's automatic, and it is officially up for sale.

The i+w x Weiss 38mm automatic 002 is a clean, classic-looking field watch with a single complication — a date window down at the 6 o'clock position — and is the second collab between the two brands.

Read more
Why you should be wearing the biggest underwear brand you’ve never heard of
Pair of Thieves is the third biggest underwear brand and they think your balls will love their fabric
Person, Body Part, Finger

I talk a lot about the importance of style. Fit, function, and fashion come together to make your personal appearance a reflection of who you are and who you intend to be. The value of quality over brand names. The importance of good tailoring over fast fashion. Wearing a suit the right way. The best shoes for your look. The way you can send a message without ever opening your mouth. But you know what I don't ever talk about? Skivvies. That's right, I don't talk about underwear. You know why? Because it is something that I (and I reckon you too) just don't think about. But, in ten minutes with David Ehrenberg, CEO of Pair of Thieves, that all changed. I started thinking about underwear. And he convinced me to try his brand, because he was certain that my balls would love it. He was right. But what is it about Pair of Thieves, and underwear in general, that made them skyrocket to the top of an industry most men don't think about?

Our goal isn't to make underwear some aspirational luxury item– it's to make it the best part of getting dressed. That's reflected in our fabric, our fit, and how closely we listen to real customer feedback. We see underwear as part of personal care, and upgrading it should feel easy, accessible, and genuinely worth it. - David Ehrenberg CEO Pair of Thieves

Read more
Peserico drops spring and summer looks in their backyard during Fashion Week
Italian staple makes news at Milan Fashion Week with their SS27 collection
Sewing, Body Part, Finger

Milan Fashion Week showed out as usual, with designers from around the world coming together to showcase what they have in store for us purveyors of menswear. Of course, the usual suspects were in attendance with the ability to continue legacies and further movements. The big ones are the ones I have been reporting here for a while now. Browns and more browns seem to remain the industry's call. Canali took it further with a spice theme, which doubled down on the color theme while deepening it. Prada took the simplistic classic aesthetics we've been seeing to what I assume is their logical conclusion. "Doing more with nothing." Continuing a theme we saw at Pitti Uomo last week, Brioni focused on the ideas of personalization and customization, bringing out the personality of your looks. And finally, Dinhill wrote a love letter to the blue blazer, calling into focus their love for the English gentleman. Out of all these campaigns, one that stood out to me was the SS27 launch from Peserico. An Italian classic with decades of quality showing off in its own backyard.

A timeless aesthetic

Read more