The Best Cover Songs That Are Just as Good as the Original

By Mark Stock May 12, 2020

whitney houston 2009 — Kevork Djansezian/Getty Images

Sometimes, a good song becomes great in the capable hands of a fellow musician. However, a good cover doesn’t just happen. It has to take a new angle, musical direction, or mood to truly stick.

Contents

Hallelujah by Jeff Buckley
Wagon Wheel by Old Crow Medicine Show
I Will Always Love You by Whitney Houston
Landslide by Smashing Pumpkins
All Along the Watchtower by Jimi Hendrix
Moon River by Frank Ocean
The Man Who Sold the World by Nirvana
Take Me to the River by Talking Heads
Respect by Aretha Franklin
Changes by Seu Jorge
Fake Plastic Trees by Christopher O’Riley
Say Hello 2 Heaven by Miley Cyrus

Lucky for listeners, there are a lot of outstanding cover songs out there. They combine to form a certain collective element of respect within the music industry — a tip of the cap from artist to artist. Sometimes they honor a musician who’s passed, other times they simply acknowledge greatness by way of a new voice.

Related Reading

Here are some of the best cover songs.

Hallelujah by Jeff Buckley

Leonard Cohen wrote the original and Jeff Buckley took it to new heights with his incredible vocal range. Buckley’s voice is its own powerful instrument, covering all octaves and able to pull off any distant note with ease. The short-lived singer-songwriter was always at his best with just a guitar and mic, as this track and the remarkable Live at Sin-é record reveal.

Wagon Wheel by Old Crow Medicine Show

Dylan mostly penned the original, with some help from Ketch Secor of Old Crow Medicine Show. The latter band really put its stamp on the song, some 25 years after it was originally written. It’s become something of a folk-rock anthem, great for open roads or last call at the bar (when bars come back, which they will). A little country, a little bluegrass, a little Americana-rock, the freewheeling song is a summertime hoedown waiting to happen.

I Will Always Love You by Whitney Houston

Whitney’s most famous song is also the best to get owned by on the karaoke stage. Originally written by fellow musical legend Dolly Parton, the track became pop royalty in 1992 as that song from The Bodyguard. It demonstrates Houston’s incredible stage presence and unrivaled ability to hold a note. The song spent 14 weeks atop the Billboard charts, making it one of the most successful singles of all time.

Landslide by Smashing Pumpkins

Smashing Pumpkins frontman Billy Corgan flexes his softer side with this excellent Fleetwood Mac cover. It’s hard to top Steve Nicks on the mic, but Corgan does well, treating the emotive track to some strings and soft-rock balladry. It’s a gorgeous and perhaps unexpected track from a band known to destroy amplifiers with its raw, grunge-y might.

All Along the Watchtower by Jimi Hendrix

Sometimes, a great cover becomes great because it’s something different entirely. Such is the case with this Bob Dylan song, which guitar god Jimi Hendrix completely makes his own. Fit with blistering guitar work, galloping rhythms, and busy drumming, it’s a robust rock ‘n’ roll classic. Dylan’s version was solid to begin with, but Hendrix plugged it in, turned it up to volume eleven, and set it gloriously ablaze.

Moon River by Frank Ocean

Frank Ocean can do it all, from soulful bedroom pop to Stevie Wonder-esque funk. Here, the musician takes on an oldie but a goodie in Henry Mancini’s “Moon River.” Originally sung by Audrey Hepburn in Breakfast at Tiffany’s, the track has been passed around quite a bit since. Ocean’s version is delicate and sweeping, with neatly-layered vocals and a hushed keyboard.

The Man Who Sold the World by Nirvana

Kurt Cobain would be just 53 years old if he were still with us. The Nirvana leader is sorely missed but lives on through his own dynamic work as well as creative covers like this one. It’s a David Bowie song, for those who don’t know, from the late great’s eponymous third studio LP. Nirvana gives it some rasp and edge, despite it being stripped down for the band’s famous MTV Unplugged in New York set (and album). For those who think this legendary Seattle act was just about volume and angst, this deft cover proves otherwise.

Take Me to the River by Talking Heads

An Al Green song from the start, “Take Me to the River” was given the fun treatment in 1978 thanks to David Byrne and his band the Talking Heads. So much more than the song the Big Mouth Billy Bass toy sings, this track sways to a memorable bass line and Byrne’s energetic antics. It’s not easy to convert soul to new wave, but the Talking Heads do so here effortlessly.

Respect by Aretha Franklin

Aretha practically owns this track as it has become synonymous with her iconic stature. In reality, it’s an Otis Redding joint, written in 1965. Franklin took it on two years later and immediately immortalized it. One of music’s greatest soul singers to have ever graced the earth, Franklin makes a good song required listening for all music fans. There’s a fantastic horn section, spot-on background singing, and a grooving bass line but it’s Franklin’s powerhouse vocals that run the show.

Changes by Seu Jorge

A change of language can inject greatness to a classic track. Here, Brazilian Seu Jorge adapts the David Bowie hit to Portuguese and his trusty guitar (in fact, he does so to much of the Bowie catalog, per the brilliant Life Aquatic soundtrack). It’s a bouncy, acoustic riff on the song, polished by the complex inflections of one of the prettiest languages on the planet.

Fake Plastic Trees by Christopher O’Riley

Sometimes it takes a classical pianist to demonstrate just how great your music is. Christopher O’Riley does just that with his intricate and twinkling take on the vintage Radiohead song. O’Riley admits to being a huge Radiohead fan and you can feel it in his moving work. It’s a reminder that Radiohead translates cleanly to a wide array of genres and very much belongs in the canon of great music.

Say Hello 2 Heaven by Miley Cyrus

Miley Cyrus with Temple of the Dog - Say Hello 2 Heaven

Seems like at some point, everybody has a Miley Cyrus moment. Mine came late on but when it did, it hit hard. With “Say Hello to Heaven,” the pop star belts one of the greatest supergroup numbers of all time, one that’s not at all easy to cover. The original features a vocal god in Soundgarden’s Chris Cornell, who has one of the most recognizable voices in all of music. Cyrus more than matches their intensity and delivery with this impassioned cover, which came as a tribute performance in the wake of the late Cornell’s passing in 2017.

Editors' Recommendations

Contributor

Mark Stock is a writer from Portland, Oregon. He fell into wine during the Recession and has been fixated on the stuff since…

Culture

Cigar expert recommends: The 10 best cigars for beginners

Close up of cigars in humidor at home - Briley Kenney from The Manual

If this is your first time smoking a cigar, or you smoke occasionally, and it has been a while, you want to ease into it. In other words, you don't want to dive in headfirst and start smoking something strong, like a full-bodied smoke. Not only will the flavors and experience overwhelm you, but the high nicotine concentration in the stronger cigars might also be a bit too much for you.

If you're curious, you can read a brief guide on what a cigar is supposed to taste like. The experience is different for everyone, and your taste buds may pick up more or fewer flavors than others, but that's okay. The rich, nuanced tastes will come across even in milder cigars, that is, if you choose the right one. But don't you worry. That's precisely why we're here. We'll ensure you are introduced to flavorful, enjoyable cigars ideal for beginners and novice smokers. Let's discuss.f
The best cigars for beginners

Culture

The 10 best Nicaraguan cigars I’ve tried and tested in 2024

Maduro cigars in a lineup ready to smoke.

Most people love Cuban cigars, but I'm not most people. I won't argue that Cuban cigars are bad; they're definitely not, but I will say they're usually popular because of the forbidden fruit situation. I would describe them as airy and light on flavor. Not bad flavor, just not particularly strong. Dollar for dollar, there are a lot of other cigars made elsewhere that are worth spending your money on because they are delicious. If I had to choose, I would go Nicaraguan almost every time.

Most Nicaraguan tobacco is grown in the small town of Esteli, and the local soil gives the tobacco its rich, complex, and full-bodied flavor. It's on my bucket list of places to visit, and I'd love to get a first-hand look at how they grow, ferment, and produce cigars -- some of the best in the industry. Nicaraguan tobacco is about as good as it gets if you like your cigars strong and memorable. And because they're so flavorful, Nicaraguan cigars are super versatile. You can smoke them in the morning with coffee, after lunch, or late in the evening, and they pair nicely with a wide variety of beverages. Moreover, they come in various strengths, sizes, and blends, from mild and medium to some of the most full-bodied cigars you'll have the pleasure of tasting.

Culture

The 8 best cigars for golfing, recommended by a cigar expert

Men drinking and playing golf, the best cigars for golfing.

Golf and cigars are a fantastic match, like peanut butter and jelly, chips and salsa, or chicken and waffles. You're outdoors, on the green most of the time, if you're a good shot anyway, and, hopefully, basking in beautiful weather. So, it's a great time to light up and enjoy a puff or two between swings or while driving around on a cart. Of course, there's always the point that you're usually multi-tasking, so you probably don't want to light up a super expensive cigar -- you won't get to enjoy it as much. What cigars are good to light up while golfing? You'll be putting it down a lot, so it needs to burn reliably and offer a relaxing, enjoyable smoke when you do puff, but also, you don't want it to break the bank and make you feel like you're missing out if you can't baby it the whole time.