The rain fell down hard against the right side of my head, as I leaned out the driver’s side window of the 2015 Jeep Cherokee Trailhawk. My co-pilot turned spotter, Peter Braun, and I had taken the all-new Cherokee to Tillamook State Forest in the Cascade Mountain Range in Northwestern Oregon to test its on- and off-road capabilities.
My soaking head was hanging out of the window not for the fun of it, but rather because I was carefully watching the front fender, as the Trailhawk inched passed an oft-gouged maple tree trunk to the left.
I slowly let off the brake pedal and inched the new, mid-size Jeep back down the muddy, rutty trail. Just as the nose of the Jeep cleared the battle-scarred tree trunk, though, my view of the trail suddenly changed.
“And now you’re on three wheels,” Peter relayed to me through the open passenger window.
“Yeah, I know. I could tell … but by how much?” I calmly asked, as I stood on the Cherokee Trailhawk’s brake pedal, holding the compact crossover in place, for fear of sliding uncontrollably down the path.
Peter squatted down next to the Cherokee and squinted. “Um … 10 inches.”
“Oh great.” I replied with trepidation, as I once again gently lifted off the brake pedal, easing the Jeep back down the trail we had just confidently climbed.
The right front wheel raised a few more inches before dropping back down into the muck, as the left front wheel finally crested a large rock it had been climbing in reverse.
With Peter’s help, I reversed the Cherokee Trailhawk back down the treacherous trail and back to the logging road off of which the trail had split. Without a doubt, the crossover could have gone further up the trail … we just didn’t know if we could.
Peter and I had come out to the off-roading recreation area known as Browns Camp to find out for ourselves whether the new “Trail Rated” Jeep crossover could truly be as capable as Jeep claimed.
We quickly found that the rig’s capabilities easily surpassed both the treachery of the Browns Camp and our nerves and off-road driving skill.
This, though, isn’t the whole Cherokee story, thankfully. Although its heart beats for the open trail, it’s much more than a rock-climber. In fact, it might just be the best crossover I’ve ever driven.
2 engines, 3 4×4 systems, 9 speeds
We’ll rejoin Peter and me on the trail in a minute. Before we do, however, let’s discuss the Cherokee’s powertrain and on-road specs.
For a quick recap, for those of you unaware, this, the fifth generation Cherokee (yes, Jeep fanatics, it is the fifth; the Liberty was a Cherokee in other global markets) is based upon a FIAT Group platform shared by the Alfa Romeo Giulietta, Dodge Dart, and new Chrysler 200. This makes it a car-based crossover.
This is only really of note for one big reason: Though more livable and efficient than ladder-frame, truck-based 4x4s, crossovers are widely understood to be less capable off road … but we’ll get to that in a bit.
The 2015 Cherokee – code named “KL” — is powered by a choice of two engines: the 2.4-liter Tigershark inline four-cylinder or a 3.2-liter Pentastar V6. The Tigershark is rated to produce 184 horsepower and 171 pound-feet of torque. The Pentastar, however, which powered my Trailhawk test vehicle, is rated at 271 ponies and 239 lb-ft.
Tigershark is estimated the EPA to achieve anywhere from 19 to 22 mpg in the city and between 25 and 31 mpg on the highway, dependent on which 4×4 level buyers choose. The Pentastar, however, is rated to achieve between 18 to 19 city and 25 to 28 highway – again, dependent on 4×4 kit.
No matter the engine option, however, Jeep pairs the gasoline burners with its new nine-speed automatic, which also routes power either the front wheels (4×2) or to all four (4×4).
If buyers decide they want a 4×4 Cherokee, they have more choosing to do, as Jeep offers three – count ‘em three — four-wheel-drive systems: Jeep Active Drive I, Jeep Active Drive II, and Jeep Active Drive Lock.
While I’ll discuss the latter more in depth later on, here are the highlights of the previous three. JADI is the simplest all-wheel drive system with only one operation: on or off. Like all the other 4×4 models, JADI operates primarily in front-wheel drive mode, disconnecting the rear axle for improved efficiency. When the vehicle senses the need for all-wheel drive, it will seamlessly – and without driver intervention – engage the rear axle.
JADII has a few more levels of 4×4 than JADI. When in 4-Low mode, the vehicle locks the front and rear drive shafts for low-speed power or towing. This mode also includes a gear ratio reduction for off-road crawling scenarios and also a one-inch increase in ride height for improved clearance.
As for Jeep Active Drive Lock, here’s how Jeep describes it: JADL includes all the features of Jeep Active Drive II and adds a locking rear differential for superior low-speed power for severe off-road conditions. JADL is standard on all Trailhawk models.
Jeep claims the Trailhawk is not only the most off-road capable vehicle in its segment, which might not surprise. What might, however, is the fact that Jeep also says the Trailhawk is also the most capable Cherokee ever.
Looking at its standard spec sheet might well demonstrate why. Along with its matte-black hood accent and red tow hooks, the Trailhawk also boasts many functional extras, including a one-inch factory lift, the aforementioned Jeep Active Drive Lock with locking rear differential, and a set of skid plates.
The “Trail Rated” badge on the side, Jeep says, “indicates that the vehicle is designed to perform in a variety of challenging off-road conditions identified by five key consumer-oriented performance categories: traction, ground clearance, maneuverability, articulation and water fording.”
On and off the trail(hawk)
Why exactly did Peter and I feel compelled to challenge the Cherokee’s ‘Trail Rated” badge? Well, Jeep, after all, has staked its reputation on being both family and mud friendly. Simply driving the new Cherokee around urban and suburban Portland wouldn’t be enough to gauge the brand’s bona fides.
No, we would have to get it dirty. So that’s exactly what we did.
Before we hit the trail, however, I stopped, put the nine-speed into neutral and clicked the Selec-Terrain traction control system into Sand/Mud setting. Then I locked the rear axle with the Jeep Active Drive Lock and also engaged 4-Low. Setting off, the Trailhawk tackled with ease and confidence every obstacle we aimed it at.
Ravines full of jagged rocks? No problem. 18-inch high, mud-covered tree roots? You bet. Even larger and more sawtoothed boulders? Oh, were those even there?
Amazingly, it easily mastered trails that I’ve personally seen highly modified, truck-based 4x4s struggle with – no small feat for a factory-fresh crossover.
As good as the Cherokee Trailhawk is off-road, it’s even better – and rightfully so — on road.
I was pretty darn skeptical of the new Cherokee, when I first saw it. My personal feelings for its front-end design aside, I wasn’t convinced a crossover that started life as an Alfa Romeo sedan could ever make a good, modern Jeep. How wrong I was.
Jeep designers were able to mate the bossiness of the Grand Cherokee in with the smaller Cherokee without faking the funk or losing the earned gravitas of the breed.
The Trailhawk’s handling is sensational. Clearly, its suspension was tuned for the trail. On the highway, though, it shines equally as bright. High-speed cornering is met without any fuss or body roll. And potholes and speed bumps are absorbed with aplomb.
High-speed, rapid braking is hugely confident – something usually and woefully lacking in most crossovers and SUVs. Acceleration, too, was excellent from the Pentastar V6. At full throttle, it gave a beefy roar. Under normal loads, though, its sounds were delightfully absent from the cabin.
It’s not just the engine noises that are absent from the cabin; so, too, are wind and road noise. The Cherokee’s cabin is shockingly quiet, which is a nice accent to its incredible attention to detail and build quality.
An example of the keenness with which the interior was designed is the center-top storage cubby. The Volkswagen Touareg features a similar cubby. It, however, looks like an ugly afterthought with weird gaps and an incongruent look. The one atop the Cherokee is a lesson in how to add utility without ruining an interior.
Just below that well-crafted cubby is one of the best infotainment systems in the industry, Uconnect on an 8.4-inch screen. If you’d like to know more about Uconnect and its wiles, check out our full review.
The rest of the interior is also outstanding, with loads of leg and headroom for both rows of passengers. Although the load floor of the rear cargo area is rather high, which cuts into usable space, it’s accessed by an electric liftgate. With an access button next to the steering wheel and also the key fob, drivers will be able to begin the opening process before they’re standing at the back of the car, even if it’s a bit slow to open.
9 speeds of worry
When it comes down to it, the Cherokee Trailhawk delighted me at every turn – it’s truly a great vehicle. That isn’t to say, however, it isn’t without its faults.
The industrial adhesives and such that make up the “new car smell” were so strong in the Cherokee that, while behind the wheel, I had the constant taste of having just licked an envelope in my mouth and often a pounding headache. These, however, like all new car smells – toxic or otherwise – will eventually fade.
More substantively, though, the Trailhawk is rated at 18 mpg city, 25 highway, with a combined score of 20 mpg. During time with it, though, I averaged 15.8 mpg during mixed driving, which isn’t very good at all when its competitors claim nearly double that.
The biggest concern I have with the Cherokee comes in the form of its nine-speed automatic transmission. Yes, the unit shifts very well and offers seamless auto start stop at traffic lights, saving precious fuel. Anecdotally, however, it might be a reliability concern. Let me explain why.
The first time Jeep put a Cherokee into the Portland fleet of press test vehicles, the car had to be sent back to Detroit after its transmission failed with around 1,500 miles on the odometer.
Not long after that, the 2015 Chrysler 200 in the press fleet, which also shares the nine-speed, also had a major transmission failure and had to be trucked back to Detroit for a postmortem.
I can’t evaluate a car’s long-term reliability based upon my singular, anecdotal evidence. Buyers should look to Consumer Reports for more substantive information on reliability. That said, the small pattern of transmission failure I’ve witnessed worries me. Heck, even the Acura TLX, which features the same nine-speed auto, is suffering from roll-away issues.
I truly enjoyed the Cherokee and I recommend it, but buyers should fully understand that they’re buying a product with an all-new, unproven transmission. If you’re OK with that potential risk, you’ll likely love the heck out of your Cherokee. If the prospect of the unknown frightens you, though, get the Honda CR-V instead.
- Handling agility
- Ride comfort
- Confident braking
- Spacious, well-crafted cabin
- Off-road capabilities
- Lower than anticipated fuel efficiency
- Polarizing front fascia styling
- Yet-unproven nine-speed automatic
- 2021 Jeep Gladiator Overland Diesel Review: Simply One of a Kind
- The 14 Best Road Trip Cars of All Time
- The Best Tire Chains for Your Car, Truck, or SUV
- The 10 Best Electric Bikes for Every Kind of Ride
- How to Drive in Snow: Our Top Tips and Gear Picks